Hey gentle readers, PCA General Assembly 2019 is this week. It’s in Dallas, Texas, and that’s a long, expensive trip to make. I wasn’t planning to go, but some of you chipped in on a Facebook fundraiser and covered my travel expenses in less than 24 hours (many, many thanks!) so that I can be there to engage in blogging and advocacy pertaining to an overture several presbyteries are attempting to bring this year. The overture is to request an Ad Interim Committee to study abuse and domestic violence in the Presbyterian Church in America. These efforts were precipitated, in part, by my abuse case involving Faith Presbyterian Church in Watkinsville, GA and Georgia Foothills Presbytery, which made it to the floor of last year’s General Assembly. You can watch that on the livestream at https://livestream.com/accounts/8521918/events/8226818 . Thursday morning business, beginning at the 1:06 mark.
I owe you all a long overdue update about how all of that went down and will try to catch up with this two part post– thanks for your patience! After last year’s General Assembly I felt semi-victorious but exhausted and had a lot that I wanted to say, but kept struggling with how to frame it for public consumption. There’s a lot of complexity in the way things turned out. My difficulty in writing about it has been exacerbated by other factors, in particular becoming aware of some extremely relevant information that intertwines with my case but that wasn’t (and in many cases still isn’t) mine to disclose. I’ve been waiting for some documents to become public, and have continued to be contacted by other survivors who have entrusted me with their stories. So to some extent I feel like I’m walking a tightrope trying to elucidate what’s happening while not compromising victims or people who are trying to be genuine advocates within the system. But I’ll do my best.
In the lead up to last year’s General Assembly, Georgia Foothills Presbytery’s flagrant, bureaucratic shrugging off of my formal complaint concerning the abuse I experienced at Faith Presbyterian Church had been flagged up in the minutes at the national level for the second year in a row. My presbytery had flatly refused to engage any of the issues I raised, dismissing my written complaint four times for the most trivial administrative reasons imaginable. The third commission assigned to my complaint never even bothered to convene in the months between presbytery meetings, and the fourth commission claimed they were dismissing it because I submitted by email rather than physical mail (which had never been cited as a problem in previous submissions and which is allowed by the Book of Church Order.) Furthermore, when I first approached the presbytery for help in the summer of 2015, its top officer at the time, the Stated Clerk, Charles Garland, called and berated me so severely for nearly two hours that I recorded most of the call and shared it with the other presbyters. Yet the presbytery did nothing about that guy either; they sent him off in good standing to lead a new church in Tucson. In 2017, the Review of Presbytery Records Committee (RPR) cited my Presbytery with an Exception of Substance requiring them to account for their actions (or more appropriately, their total lack of action.) It quietly passed in an omnibus vote on the floor of General Assembly 2017.
So in preparation for General Assembly 2018, Georgia Foothills Presbytery had assigned their biggest cronies to apply their most punctilious bureaucratic mojo to try to make this go away. They picked Roy Taylor, Stated Clerk of General Assembly, the highest officer in the whole denomination and Charles Garland’s faithful congregant until Charles went to Tucson. Roy had reportedly referred to me as “mentally unstable” in the 2017 RPR meeting (having never so much as spoken with or met me in any of the Presbytery meetings we had both attended up to that point.) The presbytery picked Jack Wilson, a lawyer in the same community as Roy and Charles, who is shown working with them repeatedly in previous General Assembly minutes. Jack had been part of the commission of two that dismissed my complaint about Charles Garland’s verbal abuse in a report riddled with factual inaccuracies, then ignored an email from Dr. Valerie Hobbs (who has written extensively about my case) documenting those inaccuracies and, to my knowledge, never corrected them for the Presbytery record. The presbytery assigned Richard Dolan, an elder in Charles Garland’s church, who around the same time was involved in prosecuting a formal indictment (which can lead to excommunication) against a couple in his congregation for “unbiblical divorce” when a woman left her abusive spouse. And the presbytery assigned Stephen Estock, director of Christian Discipleship Ministries for the whole denomination, a friendly guy who has been perfectly cordial toward me in meetings and expressed concern about abuse that I think is genuine, however has consistently urged me and my advocates to wait indefinitely for the system to somehow produce different results when it has been clear all along that the system has been working just fine to produce the results it is designed to produce.
So at the start of General Assembly 2018, Georgia Foothills Presbytery had written a sorry, thirteen page, pharisaical defense of itself intended to be bundled in an omnibus vote with other business and disposed of without even being mentioned on the floor. The only way that wouldn’t happen is if just ONE commissioner would stick his neck out to move it out of the omnibus for open debate. Various advocates and I were talking with people behind the scenes, but all of the PCA elders we knew who might be willing to do it were absent for medical or family reasons, or were not registered commissioners, or were budgeting the things they could stick their necks out for that year because of the political cost, so I arrived on the first day of General Assembly without a guy.
At the eleventh hour on the night before RPR business was scheduled, I heard from Jerid Krulish, an elder in the Pacific Northwest Presbytery who I hadn’t met, who said he would move my case out of omnibus. Hallelujah! The next day I was standing with him, another advocate, and a female friend who had come to support me who had also attended Faith Pres for a time when I saw Bob McAndrew and Steven Brooks, the senior and associate pastor of Faith, come through the lobby on their way into the auditorium. Bob looked straight ahead, woodenly, studiously avoiding eye contact. Steven made grim eye contact, and I half smiled and shrugged. (I mean come on, guys, it’s not like you didn’t have years of chances to deal with this privately. It’s not like there aren’t other victims. I still didn’t even go public on the blog until you tried to excommunicate me!)
RPR business was supposed to happen during the last session of the day. I’d had a couple of female friends with me most of the time all day long, and we were incredibly conspicuous in a sea of middle aged white guys. I was separated from them briefly during a break between meetings when several elders and one woman surrounded and confronted me in the lobby. (I’ve been made aware, after the fact, that there were people assigned to watch me while I was there. I did notice at several points that a security officer made a point of coming and walking past me, looking at me. I am apparently very frightening and intimidating, all 5’4″ of me, in a little dress, going around saying words these great, big, manly men don’t want me to say, while female. For a crowd so obsessed with traditional gender roles, some of the fellows orchestrating this stuff might not be the most convincing models of courage and fortitude.)
Stephen Estock was one of the men in the entourage and appeared to be the appointed spokesman assigned to handle me. He/they told me that they had received phone calls indicating that I might be planning some sort of demonstration in the meeting (well I had displayed “Justice, Not Abuse” on a handheld sign in church meetings before! The horror! The drama! How could anyone ever possibly recover if I did something terrible like that?) And so all these people with their tight, fake-polite smiles began to interrogate me and explain to me how to attend a meeting.
You know those times when you’re so caught off guard in the moment, when people are talking at you and ganging up on you, so you get flustered, and later on you realize “I should have said this!” and “I should have said that!” but when it’s happening, you’re tongue tied, and so you just lamely take it and then kick yourself later?
Yeah, this was NOT one of those times.
Stephen was perhaps unaware that the report he helped author was about to be moved out of omnibus and I decided not to mention that yet, but when he asked if I was planning some kind of demonstration, I said, “it doesn’t look like that’s going to be necessary but I like to see you a little nervous.” (We have a rapport, guys. Or we did before this post. 😉 FWIW, I have a general policy of naming officers/staff members while anonymizing non-officers in public discourse and this was a public action pertaining to a public document.) As I recall, he started to say something familiar about letting the system work over time, and mentioned a seminar on abuse and domestic violence that had already taken place that morning at General Assembly. (My friends and I listened to the recording of that seminar later. The woman teaching it opened with nervous jokes to the effect that she shouldn’t say anything too strong about abuse with her elders there in the room, and proceeded to pose, but not answer, various questions about domestic violence and “how do we handle it?” for 30 minutes. When she finally got around to saying anything substantive, she indicated that you should try to get an abused woman to return to her abusive husband but not tell her that’s the plan up front. This is not progress!) Anyway, Stephen said I needed to give the system time to work and I said something to the effect of “Look. You’re one of the authors of the report excusing Georgia Foothills that y’all are going to try to dispose of in omnibus in the next meeting. That’s not ‘giving the system time to work.’ That’s using the system to make this go away. If you want to fix the system and all these constitutional constraints you guys all keep wringing your hands about, why aren’t you using your status as a commissioner to bring THAT overture to the floor? Why aren’t you writing legislation to remove the alleged constraints that supposedly kept you guys from addressing my case instead of playing BCO ‘Simon Says’ to make it go away?” He sort of flustered around asking how they were supposed to know what that would even look like. I think I said they should make a responsible effort to figure that out if they presumed to be the authorities in the church. Then I excused myself, got my friends, and went into the meeting.
Other agenda items ran long, so we were in the last few minutes of Assembly business when Jerid Krulish went to the mic and moved my case out of omnibus. It was the last major thing that happened before the meeting adjourned. As a result, everyone knew it would be discussed on the floor the next morning. I watched some of the commissioners I believed to be sympathetic leave together in deep discussion.
Part two is coming soon but I have to catch a plane to Dallas! Peace, y’all!